Install the appInstall the appPitchside Lab · free · no ads
Pitchside Lab
Model 1.2

Home › Football › US Open Cup › Columbus Crew v St. Louis City

Back
USA flag

Columbus Crew v St. Louis City

Columbus Crew
0–0After penalties
St. Louis City

US Open Cup · THU 22 OCT · ScottsMiracle-Gro Field

After 90 minutesGraded 22 Oct 04:05
Columbus Crew 0–0 St. Louis City COLUMBUS CREW WIN · WRONGOVER 2.5 · WRONGBOTH TO SCORE · WRONGOVER 1.5 · WRONGUNDER 3.5 · RIGHT1–1 EXACTLY · WRONG
We said Columbus Crew win50%
The market said43%
Brier score, this match · lower is better0.904
The market’s Brier score0.822

Every number we publish is for the 90 minutes, so this match is graded on 0–0, the score after 90 minutes. St. Louis City won 3–5 on penalties.

The prediction on this page is exactly as published before kick-off. Match events and statistics come from the match and are corrected when the official figures change. Wrong calls are shown exactly like right ones.

The match replay13 notes · 22 alerts
  1. 0′Before kick-off: we said Columbus Crew win at 50%.
  2. 1′Much as we predicted: Columbus Crew was 50% before kick-off and our model makes it 49% now. 0–0 · 49–24–27
  3. 1′KICK-OFF Columbus Crew v St. Louis City
  4. 45′OUR NUMBER MOVES DOWN · 45' Columbus Crew win: 50% at kick-off, 40% now
  5. 45′HALF-TIME Columbus Crew 0–0 St. Louis City
  6. 45′SECOND HALF Columbus Crew 0–0 St. Louis City
  7. 51′We said Columbus Crew at 50%. It is not going that way — our model now has it at 38%. 0–0 · 38–38–24
  8. 55′We expected about 3.3 goals. There have been none, and the clock is running down. 0–0 · 40–35–25
  9. 55′THE CALL SWINGS · 55' Draw is now our likeliest result at 41% (was Columbus Crew win 38%)
  10. 59′We said Columbus Crew at 50%. It is not going that way — our model now has it at 34%. 0–0 · 34–44–22
  11. 66′OUR NUMBER MOVES DOWN · 66' Columbus Crew win: 50% at kick-off, 30% now
  12. 67′We said Columbus Crew at 50%. It is not going that way — our model now has it at 29%. 0–0 · 29–51–19
  13. 73′We said Columbus Crew at 50%. It is not going that way — our model now has it at 24%. 0–0 · 24–59–16
  14. 75′SUBSTITUTION · 68' Columbus Crew · On: G. Tapia · Off: J. Martinez
  15. 77′OUR NUMBER MOVES DOWN · 77' Columbus Crew win: 50% at kick-off, 20% now
  16. 78′We said Columbus Crew at 50%. It is not going that way — our model now has it at 19%. 0–0 · 19–68–13
  17. 81′SUBSTITUTION · 78' St. Louis City · On: D. Downs · Off: S. Jeong
  18. 81′SUBSTITUTION · 78' St. Louis City · On: B. Lundt · Off: R. Burki
  19. 83′We said Columbus Crew at 50%. It is not going that way — our model now has it at 12%. 0–0 · 12–79–9
  20. 83′🟨 YELLOW · 83' Columbus Crew
  21. 84′SUBSTITUTION · 84' Columbus Crew · On: S. Bangoura · Off: D. Chambost
  22. 85′SUBSTITUTION · 84' Columbus Crew · On: B. Lennon · Off: M. Farsi
  23. 85′OUR NUMBER MOVES DOWN · 85' Columbus Crew win: 50% at kick-off, 10% now
  24. 86′We said Columbus Crew at 50%. It is not going that way — our model now has it at 9%. 0–0 · 9–84–7
  25. 90′The 90 minutes are over: our published call is settled on that score. For the result after extra time our model now makes the draw likeliest at 44%. 0–0 · 34–44–22
  26. 92′We said Columbus Crew at 50%. It is not going that way — our model now has it at 4%. 0–0 · 4–93–3
  27. 101′🟨 YELLOW · 90+11' St. Louis City
  28. 102′SUBSTITUTION · 90+1' Columbus Crew · On: E. Bailly · Off: T. Habroune
  29. 103′🟨 YELLOW · 90+12' St. Louis City
  30. 104′🟨 YELLOW · 104' St. Louis City
  31. 118′🟨 YELLOW · 118' Columbus Crew
  32. 118′SUBSTITUTION · 105' St. Louis City · On: T. Ostrak · Off: S. Becher
  33. 118′SUBSTITUTION · 113' Columbus Crew · On: A. Herrera · Off: A. Zaroury
  34. 120′The 90 minutes are over: our published call is settled on that score. The shoot-out decides who goes through - our model does not price it. 0–0 · 0–100–0
  35. 154′The 90 minutes are over: our published call is settled on that score. For the result after extra time our model now makes the draw likeliest at 96%. 0–0 · 2–96–1
  36. FTFULL TIME Columbus Crew 0–0 St. Louis City
  37. FTColumbus Crew 0–0 St. Louis City after 90 minutes, as graded · Columbus Crew win: wrong · Over 2.5: wrong · Both to score: wrong · Over 1.5: wrong · Under 3.5: right · 1–1 exactly: wrong

What our live read said during the match, as it was said, with the score and our numbers for home–draw–away at that moment; and every alert we raised, with the minute. Nothing is written after the final whistle.

AI match analysis

Pitchside prediction · before kick-off

Columbus Crew are favourites.

The Pitchside prediction: Columbus Crew 50%, draw 23%, St. Louis City 27%. Over 2.5 goals 63%, both teams to score 63%.

The AI’s read on Columbus Crew v St. Louis CityBefore, during and after the match · From £5.99 + VAT · paid once, never renewsSee the passes

Pre-match prediction

First published 16 Oct 00:00 · locked at kick-off

Columbus Crew win50%
Draw23%
St. Louis City win27%

Kick-offTHU 22 OCT · 01:00

RoundFinal

VenueScottsMiracle-Gro Field

Line-ups

Columbus Crew

St. Louis City

Rest & schedule

Before kick-off · every competition we cover

Columbus Crew

St. Louis City

4Days since last match5

Last match: 18 Oct · Major League Soccer

Last match: 17 Oct · Major League Soccer

3Matches in previous 14 days3

Counted across every competition we cover, before kick-off. Friendlies are not counted.

Match statistics

Match statistics aren’t available yet.

Line-ups

Columbus Crew

Formation not confirmed

1 N. Hagen

31 S. Moreira

25 S. Zawadzki

18 M. Amundsen

23 M. Farsi

7 D. Chambost

16 T. Habroune

21 A. Zaroury

10 B. Mendez

8 S. Rodriguez

77 J. Martinez

Coach · Laurent Courtois

Substitutes

24 · E. Bush

3 · E. Bailly

2 · A. Herrera

11 · B. Lennon

17 · S. Bangoura

50 · T. Karumanchi

33 · G. Tapia

St. Louis City

Formation not confirmed

1 R. Burki

5 L. MacNaughton

32 T. Baumgartl

21 D. Polvara

6 C. Wallem

8 C. Durkin

24 D. Edelman

14 T. Totland

77 S. Jeong

19 C. Holse

11 S. Becher

Coach · Yoann Damet

Substitutes

39 · B. Lundt

20 · Rafael Santos

99 · J. Orozco

27 · F. Fall

7 · T. Ostrak

59 · M. Joyner

42 · D. Downs

Our number · columbus crew winFirst published 16 Oct 00:00 · updated 19 Oct 00:45 · locked at kick-off
50% The market43%
Us50%
Market43%

We make Columbus Crew a 50% chance to win. The market has them at 43%. We are 7 points more confident than the market. The model expects 1.9–1.4.

What the number rests on

Our model
Expected goals · Columbus Crew v St. Louis City1.90 – 1.35
Form · US Open Cup this season · since 15 AprW4 D0 L0 · W3 D1 L0
The market · Columbus Crew win43% · ours 50%

Built from every result and the chances each side creates and concedes, recent matches counting most, with home advantage in it. Line-ups, injuries and rest are not in the number.

How the number movedSince we published
35%40%45%50%55% 16 OCT 00:0022 OCT 00:44
Our probability · Columbus Crew win The market, margin stripped

Published at 49%, 50% now. No bookmaker had priced it when we published; the market has it at 43% now.

Every market, from one calculation
MarketUsMarketGap
Columbus Crew win50%43%+7
Draw23%26%−3
St. Louis City win27%30%−3
Over 2.5 goals63%58%+5
Both teams to score63%61%+2
Over 1.5 goals84%79%+5
Over 3.5 goals41%38%+3
Columbus Crew or draw73%70%+3
Columbus Crew clean sheet26%––
St. Louis City clean sheet15%––

Every figure here is read off one scoreline distribution, so no two can contradict each other. The market is the median of 6 bookmakers, each with its margin stripped — what we are measured against, never an input to the model.

Every scorelineMost likely 1–1 at 10.5%
0123450 4.6 4.7 3.6 1 6.8 10.5 6.7 3.0 2 7.0 9.3 6.3 2.8 3 4.4 5.9 4.0 4 2.1 2.8 5
under 2% 5% 12%+Columbus Crew down, St. Louis City across0–5 goals a side shown (98.3% of outcomes)

This is a probability, not a recommendation. We take no bets and hold no affiliate relationships with any gambling operator. Model 1.2 — Pitchside Lab's own model.

Head to head

2 meetings since 2023
Goals a meeting3.00
Over 2.52 of 2
Both scored2 of 2
Last meetingsSTL 1–2 COL · COL 2–1 STL

Every competition we cover, the latest meeting first.

Form · US Open Cup this season · since 15 Apr

COLUMBUS CREW

WWWW3–0 · 4–1 · 1–0 · 2–1

ST. LOUIS CITY

WWDW4–0 · 2–1 · 2–2 · 3–0